Divorce Among Conservative Protestants: What’s the Story?

There’s a new study out reporting that not only are divorce rates higher in parts of the country where there is a large concentration of Conservative Protestants, but that these people are also influencing their neighbors to be more divorce-prone. Very bad news indeed.

That is, if it were true, which there is good reason to conclude it is not. Here is a very good analysis of the study itself from the folks at the Institute for Family Studies.

It seem implausible that one could deduce a causational link between Conservative Protestants and higher divorce rates in a community. This has been done before by others and incorrectly. Many scholars have asserted that it is more of what I call a “mobile-home belt” problem, than a bible-belt problem. The authors of this study said they controlled for income/poverty, but I don’t think it can be dismissed that easily. Also it is, as this study admits, it is a “couples marrying and having babies very young” problem – which does increase likelihood of divorce – and they connect this with being consistent with Conservative Protestant teaching. This is a pretty creative leap.

And a side note worth mentioning: Jennifer Glass, who is a fine scholar, is also a leading scholar with the Council on Contemporary Families, a group of academics founded to explain that the married mom/dad/children family triad is certainly “not-all-that” and nearly all alternative family forms are worth being really excited about. This has no impact on how this particular study should be judged – as it should be on its own merits – but it does reveal clear partisanship of the author to a particular family ideal: traditional is bad, new alternative is good.

Anyway, the study is in the news this week, so thought I would offer some additional insight that students of the family should know about.

Advertisements

About glenn stanton

researcher, speaker, skater, commentator, writer, friend
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Divorce Among Conservative Protestants: What’s the Story?

  1. Divorce rates are naturally going to be higher in states with higher marriage rates. Liberals like to point to the low divorce rate of Massachusetts — without bothering to mention the pitifully low marriage rate. After all, you can’t get a divorce if you don’t even bother to marry in the first place!

  2. sanctifying.victory says:

    Perhaps it has something to do with the Protestant Church being so incredibly soft on divorce. Show me a church that ignores the fact that our Lord and Savior specifically stated his complete opposition to divorce, and I’ll show you a church that is absolutely riddled with it (39%).

    Divorced women write checks. Churches don’t want to offend writers of checks. If we were a tenth as hard nosed about divorce, and the absolute devastation it has on children (as an adult child of divorced parents I know of what I speak) as we are at porn-shaming men, then the church might have some credibility. As it stands, the Protestant Church should just shut up about marriage, including gay marriage, entirely. You are complete hipocrites.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s